Floor condition disputes are one of the most common friction points between landlords and outgoing or incoming tenants. Here's how to set — and meet — reasonable expectations.
"Fair wear and tear" versus "tenant damage" is one of the most common points of friction at handover — and floors, being the largest visible surface in most units, are a frequent flashpoint. Setting clear expectations upfront saves a lot of disagreement later.
Here's a practical guide to what's generally considered reasonable wear, and how landlords can manage floor condition proactively.
Some floor changes are expected over any tenancy: minor scuff marks from furniture, slight dulling of the finish from foot traffic, and small surface scratches are generally considered normal wear rather than damage a tenant is liable for.
What typically crosses into liability territory is different in kind, not just degree: deep gouges, burn marks, water damage from negligence (like an overflowing washing machine left unattended), or stains from spills that weren't cleaned up. The distinction matters for any deposit discussion, and it's worth documenting condition clearly at both move-in and move-out.
| Floor Condition | Generally Considered |
|---|---|
| Light scuffs, minor dulling | Fair wear and tear |
| Furniture indentation marks | Fair wear and tear |
| Deep scratches from dragged furniture | Often tenant-related, case dependent |
| Water damage from negligence | Typically tenant liability |
| Water damage from a building leak | Typically landlord/building responsibility |
General guidance only, not legal advice — specific liability depends on the tenancy agreement terms and individual circumstances.
Illustrative frequency based on common landlord-tenant friction points — not a statistical survey.
A well-documented move-in condition report is the single most useful tool for resolving floor disputes fairly at the end of a tenancy — far more useful than trying to reconstruct the original condition from memory later.
Preparing a unit for a new tenancy? WhatsApp us to get floors assessed and documented.
WhatsApp a Photo NowWe provide honest condition assessments landlords can use for move-in documentation, plus the repair or polishing work to match.
View This Service →WhatsApp us a few photos and we'll tell you honestly what your floor needs — no obligation.